In a stunning revelation that has sent shockwaves through the AFL community, Collingwood Football Club’s General Manager of Football, Charlie Gardiner, has admitted to making the controversial decision to fire premiership-winning head coach Craig McRae. The announcement, which comes amid mounting speculation and internal tension at the club, marks a seismic shift for one of the league’s most high-profile teams.
Gardiner, speaking at an impromptu press conference earlier today, confirmed that the decision to part ways with McRae was not taken lightly, but was “necessary for the long-term direction and unity of the football department.” Though Gardiner stopped short of detailing all the specific causes behind the sacking, he acknowledged there had been a significant internal fallout between McRae and several senior figures within the club.
“This is not about a single game, a single season, or a win-loss record,” Gardiner stated. “It’s about alignment. In recent weeks, it became increasingly clear that there were philosophical differences and a breakdown in communication between Craig and key elements of the football program.”
Sources close to the club suggest the relationship between McRae and several senior players had grown tense following a string of tactical disagreements and selection decisions during the back half of the season. These tensions reportedly spilled over into coaching staff meetings, where differing visions for the team’s future came to a head.
McRae, who led Collingwood to a memorable premiership in 2023 and earned widespread praise for his calm demeanor and player-first approach, has yet to issue a formal statement. However, those close to him say he is “shocked and deeply disappointed” by the decision, particularly given the club’s relatively strong performance in recent seasons.
The abrupt move has left fans divided. Many took to social media to express outrage, questioning the logic behind firing a coach with a proven track record and a strong rapport with players. Others speculated that deeper cultural issues may be at play, with Gardiner possibly using McRae’s dismissal as a way to reassert authority over a divided football department.
Club President Jeff Browne has so far remained silent on the matter, fueling further speculation that internal power dynamics may have influenced the timing and nature of McRae’s departure.
In the meantime, assistant coach Hayden Skipworth is expected to take over as interim head coach while the club begins what is sure to be an intense and highly scrutinized search for a permanent replacement.
With the AFL Finals approaching and Collingwood still considered a contender, the timing of this decision has left many stunned. Whether the bold move pays off or backfires spectacularly remains to be seen — but one thing is certain: the Magpies are now facing one of the most critical crossroads in their recent history.
