In a shock move that has sent ripples through the AFL community, Collingwood Football Club’s General Manager of Football, Charlie Gardiner, has made stunning decision regarding young defender Charlie Dean — one that has caught both fans and club insiders by surprise.
Multiple sources confirm that Gardiner has opted to delist Dean, despite earlier signs that the promising key defender was set to feature in the club’s 2026 plans. The decision was reportedly communicated to Dean and the playing group in a closed-door meeting at the AIA Centre earlier today.
A Puzzling Call
Dean, 24, was seen as a developing talent with considerable upside. After battling a series of injuries since being drafted in 2021, the former Williamstown standout finally showed glimpses of his potential in the VFL this season, earning praise for his intercept marking and composure under pressure.
While Dean hadn’t yet cemented a spot in the senior side, many believed he would be retained as a depth option heading into next year. Gardiner’s decision to cut ties now, just weeks before the trade and draft period, has left fans and AFL analysts scratching their heads.
Gardiner Speaks
In a brief but pointed statement released by the club, Gardiner addressed the call:
“These decisions are never easy, especially when it involves someone of Charlie’s character and work ethic. But after a thorough review of our list strategy and future planning, we’ve made the tough decision to go in a different direction.”
He did not take questions from the media following the statement.
Player Reaction and Fan Backlash
Some senior players were reportedly “blindsided” by the move, with one unnamed teammate telling The Age, “Charlie’s been working harder than anyone to get back — this really shocked all of us.”
On social media, Collingwood supporters expressed frustration at the lack of transparency. Many are questioning why the club would part ways with a developing key defender at a time when tall stocks remain thin.
What’s Next for Dean?
As an unrestricted free agent, Dean will now be free to explore opportunities with other clubs — and early signs suggest he may not be without suitors. Several rebuilding sides, including North Melbourne and Hawthorn, are reportedly monitoring his situation closely.
A source close to Dean said he was “disappointed but determined,” and will “do everything possible to stay in the AFL system.”
Broader Implications
The decision raises questions about the internal dynamics at Collingwood and hints at potential changes coming to the club’s list management approach. With the Magpies expected to be active during the upcoming trade period, this could be the first of several surprise moves under Gardiner’s leadership.
As the dust settles, one thing is clear: Gardiner’s bold call on Charlie Dean has set the tone for what could be a dramatic off-season at the Holden Centre.
